[Alupis]

> Not sure I follow why you had to turn to docker

I didn't, and OP could have stuck with Java8 since it's LTS. So I'm not sure either where Docker comes into play. It seems the parent was deploying fat jars, and now due to the complications of all the various deps, they opted to use Docker images as a new "fat jar". Perhaps it simplified their build process, but that's just a guess.

> The JVM is deterministic - I don't follow this statement?

Custom classloading simply requires a string path and FQN of the class to attempt to load it from disk. Compile time checking doesn't validate the actual existence of the class, which is the point of runtime custom class loaders.

A lot of plugin loaders are done this way, etc. So... your program might be humming along just fine until it classloads in a plugin (or whatever) that depends on Jaxb for example, then everything explodes since Jaxb is now a dep instead of built into the jdk.

[_hilro]

Sure but that's always been the case.

Anyways, I had read your comment as: ~"Classloader loads class X fine one moment and then suddenly can't" which is why I mentioned deterministic.

[Alupis]

> Sure but that's always been the case.

Well, no it hasn't. Things like Jaxb, for example, have always existed in the JDK since they were introduced (java 1.2 in Jaxb's case). XML processing code compiled with jdk5 (circa 2004) still worked fine on java8, for example, with zero code or dep changes. Suddenly that assumption is broken with java9.

> Anyways, I had read your comment as...

It was just an admittedly contrived scenario where the upgrade path to jdk9+ wasn't as straight forward as just adding deps to maven and calling it a day, since you may not be aware of all code interactions, depending on the system you're upgrading.

Your program might even have a dep on some jar that was compiled under jdk4 and the author and source are nowhere to be found (or went out of business a decade ago)... and suddenly it breaks under java9. Things like that are largely what prevented mass adoption of jdk9 immediately.