Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zepto 1742 days ago
> as interviewed by bbc reporters.

Do you have a link to this report? I can’t find one.

1 comments

Ok, so tweets, not ‘the BBC’
OP said "bbc reporters", not "the BBC", and the first Tweet is from a BBC reporter.
Even if they do report for the BBC at other times, they aren’t reporting for the BBC in this tweet. The BBC being mentioned here is misleading.

The fact remains that these are just tweets and there is no fact checked reporting of it by the BBC or any other journalistic outlet that I can find.

>Even if they do report for the BBC at other times, they aren’t reporting for the BBC in this tweet.

Right, hence the use of the phrase, "bbc reporters" and not, "the BBC". Given how common it is for reporters to tweet like this these days, that's a natural assumption one could - and should - be making when they read phrases like that. That was the very assumption that I made when I first read the comment.

>The BBC being mentioned here is misleading.

Not really, it's just saying, "Someone an outlet like the BBC trusts." Which is to say that while a claim hasn't been confirmed, it has a higher likelihood of being true relative to if you, myself, or any old Joe Schmoe had made the claim. That doesn't necessarily mean we should automatically assume it's true, but it also doesn't necessitate a complete write-off.

> "Someone an outlet like the BBC trusts."

The BBC clearly has not trusted these reports. Nor has any other journalistic outlet.

They are literally just the tweets of any old Joe Schmoe. It doesn’t matter who they work for, since the BBC is not taking any responsibility for the reports.

Journalism has fact checkers and editors for a reason.