Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cousin_it 5427 days ago
Awesome! But actually I think my comment was inadvertently a bit more illuminating than the SICP exercise :-) Despite being on the web, SICP is a "traditional" textbook and doesn't bother to link to Wikipedia. Instead they use some sort of stone-age technology called "footnotes", stuffing all supplementary material right into the book as a couple lines of tiny text. So the student gets the feeling of following a twisty cluttered rabbit hole instead of exploring a new land.
2 comments
BDFL_Xenu 5427 days ago
Well, SICP was a printed book before being put on the web (as it is quite a few years older than it), and the version you see on the webpage is just a rendition of it in HTML. Still, I didn't know until today that you could link to individual figures and exercises, it will be even more fun to cite it in a quasi-religious, trollish way.

Also, you generalized the principle (and fused two exercises of the book in one :), or at least I'll have to believe you ;) I didn't form really much of an intuition on eigenvectors during the completely proper Linear Algebra course that I took, which is only my fault.

But I think that the exercise serves to reinforce the underlying theme that with enough attention, one can either supply or draw the insight to chip away yet one more part of the problem, to attack it from another angle, to pull it from just another direction that one had not seen before. It celebrates cleverness and knowledge, used to make complex things simple, to find the easy way out the hard way and end up better in the end, and that's partly why it's so cherished, but we all know that.

link
prakashk 5422 days ago
> Instead they use some sort of stone-age technology called "footnotes", stuffing all supplementary material right into the book as a couple lines of tiny text.

A bit OT.

I got tired of clicking on the footnote links, and click to come back to text, and wrote a little Greasemonkey script that shows the footnotes on mouse hover. Makes reading the text a bit easier.

It's available at http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/109690 in case anyone's interested.

link