Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rmchugh 1745 days ago
It's nonsensical in my opinion. There is no reference to relations between the "Soviet" and Soviet Russia. The only connection is the name.
2 comments

Soviet, here, just means a "workers council" rather than the bureaucratic state the term is usually associated with
according to 5 minutes of wikipedia research:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limerick_Soviet

    On Friday 11 April a meeting of the United Trades and Labour Council,
    to which Byrne had been a delegate, took place. At that meeting Irish
    Transport and General Workers' Union (ITGWU) representative Sean
    Dowling proposed that the trade unions take over Town Hall and have
    meetings there, but the proposal was not voted on.[5] On Saturday 12
    April the ITGWU workers in the Cleeve's factory in Lansdowne voted
    to go on strike. On Sunday 13 April, after a twelve-hour discussion
    and lobbying of the delegates by workers, a general strike was called
    by the city's United Trades and Labour Council.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_Transport_and_General_Wo...

    The union was founded by James Larkin in January 1909 as a general
    union.[1][2] Initially drawing its membership from branches of the
    Liverpool-based National Union of Dock Labourers, from which Larkin had
    been expelled, it grew to include workers in a range of industries. The
    ITGWU logo was the Red Hand of Ulster, which is synonymous with ancient
    Gaelic Ulster.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Larkin

    James Larkin (28 January 1874 – 30 January 1947), sometimes known as Jim
    Larkin, was an Irish republican, socialist and trade union leader. He was
    one of the founders of the Irish Labour Party along with James Connolly
    and William O'Brien, and later the founder of the Irish Worker League
    (a communist party which was recognised by the Comintern as the Irish
    section of the world communist movement), as well as the Irish Transport
    and General Workers' Union (ITGWU) and the Workers' Union of Ireland
    (the two unions later merged to become SIPTU, Ireland's largest trade
    union). Along with Connolly and Jack White, he was also a founder of the
    Irish Citizen Army (ICA; a paramilitary group which was integral to both
    the Dublin lock-out and the Easter Rising). Larkin was a leading figure
    in the Syndicalist movement.[3]
So a strike instigated by a union founded by syndicalist who also founded revolutionary unions endorsed by the cominform, who was yet to pivot to the NEP and still advocating global union based insurrection to trigger socialist revolution.

Doesn't mean the proto-SU planned this activity particularly, but claiming 'no connection' when people involved were part of global revolutionary activity directly connected to groups descending from the internationale and associated with the cominform is also just as tenuous if not moreso.

You have no idea what you're talking about.