Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by uDontKnowMe 1738 days ago
Really dislike the "written in Rust" suffix all the time...
1 comments

Why?
Because it being written in rust is only added to the title to attract the attention of evangelists. The rest of us don't care what its written in.
It's a useful signal though right?

This being written in Rust tells me it's probably going to be fast/lightweight. Go would be a similar expectation. If it's written in Rails I'd have different expectations. Python or Node might fall somewhere in the middle.

This project is a webserver you can host yourself, so having an idea of the resources required is very helpful.

> This being written in Rust tells me it's probably going to be fast/lightweight. Go would be a similar expectation. If it's written in Rails I'd have different expectations. Python or Node might fall somewhere in the middle.

Which is exactly why the language doesn't matter. It being written in rust doesn't tell you anything, and serves only to evoke some predisposition you have for rust. There's nothing in rust that stops users from writing horrible algorithms. This reddit front end could send separate requests for every letter it loads for all you know.

That's why it matters that it's also open source.

It's similar to Big-O notation, seeing that it's in Rust gives me an idea of performance profile to expect. If it's a Rails project I know that the best case scenario is fairly resource intensive, no matter how good the code is. If it's Rust then I know that for an average quality open source project it will be lower resource usage. If a project ends up being terribly inefficient after that, I'll drop it regardless of what stack it's in.

Knowing what tech stack something uses is a valuable first signal.

Hm, I am not so sure about this. After all the site that you browse has a title of Hacker News. For me the information about "being written in rust" is exactly what I expect to read here.
FWIW, I really like knowing that X was written in Y. If I'm learning Y, it gives me another thing I could look at and see if I can pick up something useful. If I already know Y, it might still be interesting to see if there's anything special about writing X in Y, instead of or compared to Z.

It's a bit disheartening to watch gripes like this become more and more common on HN. It used to be a place where people were a lot more interested in sharing points of view and exchanging information, than criticizing anything that can be criticized.

> The rest of us don't care what its written in.

Given that there are a few ecosystems that I actively avoid reading about (e.g. anything nodejs), I appreciate them being stated in the title.