Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dr_faustus 1749 days ago
No biochem, but from what I read, it was highly doubtful that the product could even theoretically work because blood is not a completely homogeneous fluid. Concentrations of the things you want to test for vary by quite a lot if you take tiny samples from different places (esp. blood from small capillaries like in the finger tip).

That's (at least one reason) why "normal" blood draws are quite a lot of blood. By thoroughly mixing the drawn blood, you get a much better approximation of the average concentration throughout the body.
1 comments
NoPie 1749 days ago
The counterpoint is Freestyle libre sensor. It measures glucose levels not in the blood but intercellular liquid and while not as precise as blood test, it is working.

Even if blood in capillaries is different, the measurements can still be meaningful if those differences are systematic and can be accounted for. We just need better science and technology to make use of it.

link
dr_faustus 1749 days ago
Again, no expert, but glucose, insulin levels and blood oxygen have been measured in a drop of blood forever, so I guess they are sufficiently homogeneous and also available in sufficient amounts even in small drops of blood for that to work. But the promise of Theranos was that basically every serological test could be performed on a drop of blood (even many tests with the same drop).
link
NoPie 1749 days ago
I don't see it impossible if you account for expected changes. It probably needs a lot of more research and better technologies, so we are not there yet.
link