Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by emrah 1749 days ago
I'm thinking about a PF app concept where you enter your own transactions manually, but you don't have to keep track of everything down to the cent.

At the end of every month, banks send out statements so importing all transactions aren't necessary to keep track of one's overall financial standing.

Banks do make mistakes but extremely rarely that it's not worth wanting to import all transactions in the off chance that you'll catch a mistake. Retailers can make mistakes like double charge you but again those are rare and you can take a quick look at your statements to find them usually.

Keeping track of individual transactions are important to be able to figure out where the money is going in general but this doesn't require keeping track of 'every' transaction. Just the ones that make up the biggest percentage of the total money spent. They are usually easy to spot on the bank/creditcard statements.

One doesn't even have to be perfectly accurate to gain from inspecting statements either. You spent $834.56 for new tires? You can enter that as $850 and it's fine.

Sure, there might be cases where the total is split more or less evenly across several small transactions and that can be handled similarly to the above.

Knowing where the money is going isn't terribly useful actually unless there are a lot of frivolous spendings. It usually comes down to "you are not making enough money" or "the lifestyle you desire is too expensive for your current income". No app can fix either of these, other than point out the obvious problem. Most personal finance blogs end up leaning towards "how to earn more" because that's more important than keeping track of your transactions or budgeting.

1 comments

This is the philosophy behind the FOSS app I developed for my own system. The way it works is that I track the big stuff and ignore the little stuff. Periodically (typically every month but it doesn't have to be) I enter the current balances of my bank accounts.

I have a report that does how much money I spent per period that is unaccounted for, that's money that got spend on "miscellaneous". As long as that number is beneath some threshold that I consider acceptable I let it be. If it's high, I might look back and try to determine where my money went and make adjustments.

The guiding principle behind this approach is resilience to laziness. It's not an all or nothing system, instead it gives me whatever I give it. If I am busy and don't enter as many transactions, no worries - I'll just have more in the miscellaneous category. If I don't track my balances every month, the period will be longer. But the system always "balances".

The system also serves as a log for bigger purchases. When did I buy that fridge? How much did I pay? What is the exact model number of that piece of equipment in case I need to buy it again? I can search my transaction log.

Awesome! Could you provide a link for it?
I'd rather not link my HN profile to github which uses my real name. I went to you profile to see how I could send it to you directly but...there's no email listed on your site or github and I can't message you on Twitter (I guess that's a setting?)

Anyway, while it's FOSS it's not really packaged for easy reuse. You'd need to set up a server and configure it. It might be good as inspiration or as a starting point for your own project though, so you're still interested I can log in to LinkedIn later and message you there.

Ah yes, that's true, thank you for trying. I didn't expose email on purpose. You are right LinkedIn would be the only way for now if you didn't want to post it publicly.