Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by MattGaiser 1756 days ago
The goal of most personal finance experts is not to teach you to be mega rich, but rather to be average and while still being pretty average in terms of income, hours worked, and capability, remarkably comfortable to peers.

> Yet you almost never hear the financial experts recommending that you start a business.

Is the average business owner any better off? I know that there are plenty of successful business owners, but we tend to completely ignore the many that filed bankruptcy after taking cash advances on credit cards to live one more month.

> Nor do these guys tend to mention the importance of understanding how taxes work.

Only really matters if you make a lot of money. My Dad is a tax accountant. We optimize the heck out of our personal taxes. But at our 100Kish incomes, it doesn't make a big difference beyond what the personal finance people say.

2 comments

> Is the average business owner any better off?

Obviously anecdotal, but not really IMO. I've bounced back and forth between being in business for myself and working for the man.

Between healthcare, saving for retirement, etc. things are really optimized against someone "pulling themselves up by the bootstraps" in this way. I've listened to the politicians in the US scream how important small business only to vote against that very interest (tax cuts for rich + corporate tax breaks).

I can't get good healthcare unless it's tied to my employment here. The healthcare I get independently is of lower quality for much, much more money out of pocket... Lord help you if you do something stupid and show a profit on your books... etc etc... The first 2-3 rungs of the "small business owner" ladder are missing by design.

If I had a family I would likely never consider being a business owner again due to the health implications, financial risk, and time commitment.

100% the average working Joe is better off.

"small business" to national politicians typically means you employee under 500 people. Almost no one considers "self-employed" or "1-3 people" as "small business" when crafting tax legislation. I certainly consider "self-employed" and "I have a couple folks on payroll" to be "small business", but it's just not in the same league as the local brewery employing 85 people, for example.

Perhaps we need the term "micro business" to gain more traction? I suspect that's where more work is heading.

I think micro-business as a term exists (and depending on the exact definition is typically 0-4 full-time employees, including the owner).
Here they're called artisans.
Starting a business is complicated, requires discipline, and then requires a decent amount of luck to even keep it afloat...

It can be used as a good tax harvesting vehicle but again this requires so much knowledge and ultimately I think running a business (even at a strategic loss) requires more depth of knowledge than the average saving/investing tips.

Would definitely agree that starting a business is a path to becoming RICH, but definitely not a path to being financial stable/above average