[matthewdgreen]

The question of whether Apple should open the "proprietary abstractions it builds on its own operating system" is a major one that is now being litigated in multiple courts and regulatory jurisdictions. My argument is simply that sophisticated iCloud integration falls into this category and should probably receive attention from those same courts and regulatory insitutions.

To the extent this is about privacy, the argument is that Apple has created an opinionated regime for scanning user photos using untested technology -- and has (quite correctly, I think) determined that privacy-conscious users should have the right to opt out. The issue here is that Apple's version of "opt out" does not allow users access to the same functionality through third-party cloud providers. Users who opt out for privacy and security reasons will be substantially worse off than users who opt in. This isn't the only reason that regulators should consider revisiting Apple's cloud integration, but it's a new and important one that did not exist before Apple announced this service.