Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by velcii 1769 days ago
>it's given the power of the press back to the people

You are mistaken. Social media and things like youtube, just like elections, provide the appearance of power and choice, but just safely let people to let out pent up emotions. Then they safely contain it without it being spilled to the real world to a certain extent, at the same time give the people who participate in them a certain feeling of "doing something", a fallacy that even I am committing right now while I write this comment down..

As Noam Chomsky said "The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum".

We already know that youtube and other media like reddit even HN "strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion", and as you said, they also allow very lively debate withing the rest of the spectrum..

1 comments

> Then they safely contain it without it being spilled to the real world to a certain extent

Like January 6th? Safe containment indeed.

> youtube and other media like reddit even HN "strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion"

Which results in an ever increasing number of extremist refugees. The Fediverse appears to be growing consistently and I think the systemic mechanisms that are concentrating extreme viewpoints there should be cause for concern.

On the plus side, if a particularly interesting video is removed from YouTube you can often find it mirrored there.