Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by neil_s 1777 days ago
As a Googler, I have this pain point. I was envisioning a product that sweeps the leftover income at the end of the month after all credit card bills and rent are paid, into a brokerage account. It would also automatically invest that amount into my choice of ETFs, which Vanguard bizarrely doesn't seem to support today. This seems to achieve the same goal with a simpler implementation, and then as you improve your cash flow predictions, you could start keeping a cash buffer and delaying investments to avoid some cash<>asset conversions.

Worrying about capital gains taxes is a head-fake - you're only paying tax on your gains, which would have otherwise been minimal interest, which btw is taxed higher than gains. The risk here is just that the amount of margin interest I pay is dependent on how quickly you're able to sell, although hopefully this shouldn't be a massive issue for VTI et al.

Your messaging on the website seems clear to me, I wouldn't worry about anyone living paycheck-to-paycheck mistaking your technical looking homepage for a regular checking account.

One of your mentioned use cases doesn't sound right though - if I'm saving up towards a short-term spending goal like a car or house downpayment, I probably want a predictable balance and not exposure to sudden price shocks.

1 comments

Thanks for the thorough writeup! I agree that our implementation seems to solve your use-case.

Let me provide you with a bit more context about the house buying use case. When buying houses you need to keep a chunk of money (around $60k) available to wire next day for a "good faith deposit" in case you're the winning bid, and it's quite a waste to keep that money in a checking or savings account (since the house buying process can take months).

Since Financial Choice only allows 50% accessible in Instant Access, in your home buying example I would need to have $120K in my account to make a $60K transfer (ignoring the possibility of a market downturn). Is a long term goal of Financial Choice for users to treat this less like a checking account where you hold cash for near term spending and more like a one-stop shop where all your assets are held?