[voidnullnil]

Am I missing something? Apple says they literally scan stuff locally on your iCrap now and call the police on you if you have $badstuff. Nobody should be having their data scanned in the first place. Is iCloud unencryped? Such a thing exists in 2021? I've been using end to end crypto since 2000. I don't understand why consumers want their devices to do all kinds of special non-utilitarian stuff (I mean I totally understand, it's called politics).

This new iCrap is like a toaster that reports you if you put illegally imported bread in it. It will be just like the toaster which will have no measureable impact on illegal imports. Even if $badguys are so dumb to continue using the tech (iCloud???) and lots go to jail, lots more will appear and simply avoid the exact specific cause that sent previous batch to jail. They do not even thave to think.

The problem with all this is that everyone is applauding Apple for their bullshit, and so they will applaud the government when they say "oh no, looks like criminals are using non-backdoored data storage methods, what a surprise! we need to make it illegal to have a data storage service without going through a 6 month process to setup a government approved remote auditing service".

Then there's also the fact that this is all a pile of experimental crypto [1] being used to solve nothing. Apple has created the exact situation of Cloudflare Pass: they pointlessly made $badip solve a captcha to view a read-only page, and provided a bunch of experimental crypto in a browser plugin to let him use one captcha for multiple domains (they would normally each require their own captcha and corresponding session cookie). They later stopped blocking $badip all together after they realized they are wrong (this took literally 10 years).

1. https://www.apple.com/child-safety/ "CSAM detection" section