Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by saulr 1772 days ago
I believe this tweet has been twisted from the original tweet, which is that _cross origin_ alert (e.g. from an iframe) is the thing being removed. Using alert etc from the main frame will continue to work.
1 comments

They are planning to deprecate them from the platform entirely, this is the first step
Please provide a link, or stop passing speculation off as truth.
Those links contradict your assertion, instead indicating a move to "non-blocking alert()"
From those links:

> Yeah, I think the most likely eventual "removal" path is actually non-blocking alert(). (confirm() and prompt() cannot be converted to non-blocking though, so they'd have to be fully removed)

Blocking Javascript execution is a fundamental part of the `alert` spec. Replacing it with a different, non-JS-blocking thing that happens to share the same name doesn't mean that `alert` wouldn't be removed as it exists today.

And there's just no way at all to make `prompt`/`confirm` non-blocking, they have to block the main JS thread in order to keep the same API.

That breaks the web by definition. There is no way to implement a non-blocking alert(), confirm(), or prompt() in a way that doesn't break existing code that uses them, and that's a lot of code, a lot of the web.
It can block JavaScript execution on the page for compatibility with existing code, while leaving normal browsing unaffected otherwise.