[Verdex]

I want to second this.

My first thought was the same as yours (no way that works for everything).

It seems like a neat idea. But I can't imagine that anyone has ever done this for anything non-trivial. I want some sort of compelling argument that this works at all before I'm willing to accept this as anything else than a pipe dream.

[bob1029]

I am curious what edge cases (i.e. "non-trivial" things) you have in mind that this would not work for.

For us, the more complex the business gets, the more justified this path becomes. Our business fails to scale if we have to write custom code for every customer. Writing custom SQL per customer (against a common schema) is far more tenable.

Are you thinking of some specific logical determination that would be infeasible in SQL vs in code? Or, is this more about webscale arguments?

[Verdex]

It's the same sort of disbelief that I would have towards being introduced to a skyscraper made out of cardboard. At first I would think, "oh, this is just like concept art." ~No, we actually built it.~ "Err, so, like nobody can actually go in there." ~It supports people just fine.~ "Um, for what, 20 minutes." ~Well, Nick has lived in it for 20 years now.~

Finally, I'm not going to venture in (let alone actually live in it myself) without someone sitting me down and carefully explaining the structural integrity principles (and other logistics) that make the cardboard skyscraper possible.

Hearing business rules in sql works for some unknown entity doesn't really give any information about the viability for anything else. Maybe the initial modeling is really hard, but all your customers have near identical concerns, so you only pay that cost once. Maybe having multiple customers is actually the key because if one customer's needs violates some assumption that makes the whole thing work, you can tell them go to someplace else. Maybe your customers only have five business logic rules apiece that are all well spec'ed.

What's the domain? The industry? What problems are actually being solved? Can we have an example (even a contrived one)? Is there an open source example? How about a mathematical proof or even principle that argues for why this can be expected to always (or even nearly always) work? How about a youtube video with someone describing the approach?

EDIT: How about this. Show me a partial parser using this approach (grammar rules can be considered business logic, right). Just parse function declarations in C or something. I'll be able to project such an example onto what the full solution would look like to see if I believe it could actually work in general.

[scythmic_waves]

Your cardboard skyscraper analogy is fantastic. It does a good job capturing the tone of my disbelief.

I'm disappointed to see there wasn't a response because I was pretty willing to entertain the notion of business-logic-as-normalized-tables. But I needed, like, any evidence.