[shanebrunette]

I am the founder of CryptoTaxCalculator.io and I am not sure where the idea of non traceability on DEXs comes from. Aggregating the transaction history is absolutely possible, all we need is the public wallet address. The real black box is around certain international exchanges that don’t keep appropriate transaction records.

[BLKNSLVR]

You're right, yes. I was attempting to point out that with a DEX there is no way to enforce record keeping or KYC, and so if someone is determined to avoid tax, then DEXs won't / can't report back to a tax authority.

Australian exchanges, as far as I've gathered, proactively send transaction details to the tax office, or are compelled to do so upon tax office request.

When it comes to public wallet addresses, it becomes up to the individual to voluntarily declare their ownership - such is my understanding.

I will defer to your knowledge and / or expertise if you disagree with my understanding, you need to know this stuff inside out - congrats on founding, and here's to a big future for crypto, you're well placed.

[DennisP]

If you bought crypto on a regulated exchange like Coinbase, which does KYC, then it's pretty easy for the government to find out that it was you who funded the address. After that everything's an open book.

Theoretically you could claim that you were paying some other person, but then you'd have to explain what you paid for. And if you ever cash out your crypto to fiat, you'll have a lot more explaining to do.

Privacy technologies would obscure the on-chain transactions but still not help with the basic problem.

[onelastjob]

Yes, exactly this. As long as the fiat on-ramps and off-ramps are KYC'ed everything that happens in between is an open book. The individual can just use cryptocurrency tax reporting software to provide a trade history for their taxes, and if they don't do that then the IRS can easily track all of their transactions since the IRS will know what addresses they are sending to from exchanges. There's no need for every DEX (or other service) along the way to KYC their users.