Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tfsh 1776 days ago
It would be weird to couple together the Chrome bookmarks and Google bookmarks at https://www.google.com/bookmarks, by doing so Chrome bookmarks which is a browser specific concept would only be accessible through an internet connection, thereby making bookmarking an extension of a cloud based Google product rather than something the user can choose to decouple.

A better solution could be to automatically backup users Google bookmarks in a new folder under the Chrome bookmarks or move them to Collections which seems to be the new Google bookmarks
2 comments
skinnymuch 1776 days ago
You could easily have chrome bookmarks work offline and also sync with chrome bookmarks. Other services have been able to do this in the past. There’s likely code on GitHub that takes some managing that can do this with other bookmarking services.

If Google Maps stars were added/synced to Bookmarks, it makes sense for Chrome bookmarks to have some coupling as well when Chrome bookmark syncing was introduced.

link
jfoster 1775 days ago
Sorry, you misunderstood me. My argument was not that they should've introduced Chrome bookmarks and then merged them together.

My argument was that they should not have introduced two separate things when improving the one that already existed to simply work offline would have sufficed.

link