[gonehome]

I think we're mostly in agreement?

When you disable wifi/bluetooth via the control center, pop-up text appears saying exactly what that means. I'm not sure how they could make that more clear. It still may not be your (or my) desired default, but I at least understand the reasoning.

[mixmastamyk]

Tiny, wordy, brief text after the button press is not what I'd describe as clear. If you need to add "comments" to a (now three-state) button, it's a sign that the interface needs work.

It's extra complexity in the form of rules added to what was previously a simple to understand toggle button. That it goes against historical norms, reduces privacy, and wastes a bit of power is the icing.