|
Yeah, right? Don't get me wrong, I've found a lot of Holub's content to be great. I'm something of a fan in some senses, as it's given me a perspective to question some of the utter guff prevalent in the agile space (particularly wrt. things like Scrum and Story points). I don't buy some of it - things like cost of delay - but I'm always interested to hear more and I'm prepared to change my mind on it. But. Much like Dawkins, he ought to stay off twitter, as he comes out with crazy-town absolutist statements (like: if your organisation doesn't do X, then it's fundamentally beyond all redemption and you should just leave). A recurring theme is there in that list, particularly (20), which is - to paraphrase - "give all your money to the agile team, then go away and you have no right to question what they're doing in any way, shape, or form - you just trust them to 'do the right thing' as they're the experts". No line management, no project management, nothing. Go away and leave me alone. Now put that in context of a self started project that took nearly $15K, listed no significant risks "hey I already have most of this content anyway", has no external dependencies to blame and... completely failed to deliver. How can I take any of it seriously when the supposed expert can so utterly fail to practice what they are preaching? |