Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kumarvvr 1792 days ago
What happens to the leftover content after the methane is extracted?

Can it be used as a manure or is it safe to be dumped underground or in rivers?

3 comments

>Can it be used as a manure or is it safe to be dumped underground or in rivers?

Absolutely! A danger of human waste is that it carries a lot of pathogens that might be benign or beneficial in the lower intestine of one person but cause disease in the stomach of another, but the solution to that problem is to let it ferment/decompose for a bit and let all the bacteria kill themselves off through starvation and cooking in their own metabolic heat, and during that process is when you collect the methane. You'll often see large piles of cow manure composting in big piles for similar reasons, though the methane isn't always captured.

The danger to dumping any kind of waste into a river, treated or not, is that it will start killing anything that finds it toxic (most likely your fish and amphibians) and feed anything that finds it nutritious (algae, bacteria), which can cause ecological imbalances and generally screw up your ecosystem. For an adjacent example, look at the Gulf dead zone caused by fertilizer runoff from the American corn belt: Fertilizer feeds algae, which then chokes out other plants fish need to survive and absorb oxygen when the algae dies off, leaving a large swath of ocean without fish or anything that relies on fish.

Excellent manure, feedstock for compost. Still too toxic for dumping into rivers.
Deeply familiar with it :) and the Humanure Book goes on at length about how to compost the shit and make very sure it is safe to use. The solids that come out of a methane digester must be composted to render them safe.
I'm pretty there are all sort of health issues in using human sewage as compost. Look at North Korea for an example of that.
There are already ways of converting human waste into protein. 100kgs of human waste can be converted into 40kgs of protein.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/christinero/2019/07/06/from-fec...

Yummie Brownies!
I would like to look. Do you have some links ?
As far as I understand they have a shortage of everything, including livestock, so they end up using human feces as compost. This becomes a disease vector and you end up with ground water and vegetables contaminated with all sorts of parasites. This is specially critical for children because intestinal worms effectively hijack what little nutrients they can eat, creating even more malnourishment. [0]

[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-unicef-idUSKBN...

North Korea is also terrible example about having government at all.

IIRC the problem was that they were using improperly treated waste.