[memco]

Was just browsing a website where the first page of a query worked, but visiting page 2 of the results was returning a DNS error. Was curious how and why only part of the site was down, but it looks like this was the problem as now the whole site is down.

[katbyte]

aren't short DNS TTLs great?

[sebmellen]

Is this a serious argument for long TTLs? Always wondered why they exist… How interesting.

[slim]

Yes it is. The longer the TTL the longer you stay independent from third parties. It's what makes the internet stable.

[remram]

Long TTL makes you independent from DNS third parties, in that your name is still know by clients if DNS is down.

Short TTL makes you independent from hosting third parties, in that you can quickly change which hosting provider your domain name points to.

You can't win this one by only changing your TTL. The best solution is to use short TTLs and multiple nameservers on different providers.