[account42]

> That's even worse, because then an upgrade to the compiler in the managed CI runner (e.g. Github Actions') base-image will translate to the same version of the code failing where it previously succeeded

If you don't want your build to fail on warnings, don't use -Werror. If you want it to only fail on specific warnings, use -Werror=...

> with nobody sure why

Unless they look at the errors in the compiler output. What does it matter if it was brought on by a compiler update or a push?

> At least with -Werror on at all times, devs will tend to upgrade before the very-stable CI environment does

Nothing wrong with -Werror for devs - the problem is when you ship code to others and leave -Werror on by default.