[ankitdce]

Feels like this should be a post in itself! This is just my opinion so open to any push backs / comments.

IMO the main reasons for source control are: - having revisions / diffs that can be reviewed by someone else - while working independently in a distributed fashion - easy way to rollback to an older revision

I'm not too familiar with CRDTs, will add more comments after reading more about it, but let's take Google docs as example here. What if we were all writing code in Google docs, how would that turn out.

Google docs do a decent job of versioning, so the last point can still be satisfied. I think with a source code styled version of Google docs, one can easily tag versions and do rollbacks. The issue happens when collaborating. Just from my experience working in spreadsheets where > 10 users are actively trying to modify, overwriting each other becomes very common. You can argue that it might make it easy to also fix this, but what about running the code locally?

One would have to still take a snapshot - hope that it actually compiles. From my personal experience, while I'm writing code, it rarely compiles in the first attempt. So then we would really have to work on snapshots where we know it compiles. At that point, you are really creating "commits" and pushing it to the remote. I am not sure if we can really completely avoid conflicts in such model.