Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mickaelP38 1797 days ago
I found the first two articles were interesting despite obvious flaws in the presented evidence. After reading the third one, it just looks like logical fallacy to me.

For example, taken from the first article:

> In the past, most people got slightly leaner as they got older.

How can you claim that with so few data. From the same data I would conclude that obese people die at young age...

I don't think we should exclude any possible cause but a global contaminant which is the only cause of obesity seems far fetched.

Simple logic would suggest that our food is the main culprit.

Personaly I would bet obesity is due to weakened gut microbiome (due to consumption of process foods), transmitted from mothers to their children. In other words, each generation consuming processed food gives birth to children more susceptible to obesity. It has actually been modeled with rats (cannot find the published link though).

1 comments

>>Simple logic would suggest that our food is the main culprit.

Then, why does it happen in wild animals? They are not eating processed foods.

Even if the food is main culprit, it leads to the question of what is exactly wrong with the food?

p.s. we have enough data to understand overall historical trends and authors cite it:

https://voxeu.org/article/100-years-us-obesity

> Primates and rodents living in research colonies, feral rodents living in our cities, and domestic pets like dogs and cats are all steadily getting fatter and fatter.

All are fed with human produced food. Also as someone noted our food (raw food) is decreasingly nutritious when it comes to micronutrients and vitamins.