[dexterlemmer]

1. Yea, a road that was used for target practice during a large-scale NATO training exercise is the same as a road that could do with a bit of maintenance with painted potholes to warn people. After all, they both have potholes.

2. You are cherry picking. He also said "These are hard to locate for most languages; I wouldn't know where to look in case of C." Rust has some advantages from for example Clippy and from a very newcomer-welcoming and helpful community.

3. Rust in kernel would indeed have kernel-specific idioms. But it'll probably be very similar to other embedded Rust and relatively easy for a newcomer to pick up. (Ee'll have to wait and see, but there is good reason to expect this.) C in kernel is known to be very hard for other C developers to pick up.

4. Thanks for the info.

5. But some things are special about Rust that makes testing easy.

6. The kernel doesn't deal much with text and even when it does, it generally doesn't need to deal with encodings (let alone modern encodings). That said, text is really a nightmare in C. Even just ASCII is needlessly complex due to null-terination, badly designed functions and the regular C UB pitfalls. At least you did acknowledge it may indeed be a problem for C compared to Rust.