[kortex]

I mean, GP said "you can't have routers" and maybe I'm being dense by interpreting that as "never or almost never," but even with a generous "too hard to be practical," I still don't think it's correct.

And I explicitly said "escape hatch" meaning language feature. You don't need that much indirection to get routers in Haskell, Rust, Go, C, C++... like I fail to see how implementing routers are a barrier in strict type system languages.

Is it easier in python or js? Sure. can't? hardly.

E: here's some vtable dispatch (unless that doesn't count as "dynamic dispatch") in Rust. Looks really straightforward.

https://doc.rust-lang.org/1.8.0/book/trait-objects.html

[ukj]

What C++, Haskell, Rust, Go etc. call "dynamic dispatch" is what a router calls "static routing". The defining characteristic is that the lookup table is pre-determined and immutable at runtime.

What routers call "dynamic routing" is having the lookup table mutable at runtime.

There can be no equivalent to that in type-safe languages because when you mutate the dispatch table you lose type-safety.

[kortex]

> What routers call "dynamic routing" is having the lookup table mutable at runtime.

> There can be no equivalent to that in type-safe languages because when you mutate the dispatch table you lose type-safety.

That's exactly what I mean by escape hatches. Rust has unsafe. You can write a WTF FastInverseSqrt in Rust. You shouldn't 99% of the time. But you can.

Rust also has Box, Rc, Arc, and other tools. I'm not fluent enough in rust to know how to, but I'm quite confident and will eat my hat if you can't accomplish what is effectively a mutable vtable dispatch in Rust.

But also...why? Yeeting a function call into the void without any type knowledge seems way more bug-prone than interface/trait-based dispatch, to what benefit? Save developer time? I've spent countless dev-days of my life I won't get back debugging exactly this kind of dynamic-dispatched, json-dsl, frankly loosey-goosey untyped bullshit. There's so many better ways.