Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by duskwuff 1815 days ago
E2EE is genuinely hard to implement in the context of a chat service with server-side chat history, large (10k+ user) group chats, and multiple clients (including web applications).
2 comments

I'd flip that around and say that server-side chat history, large group chats and multiple clients are hard to implement in the context of an E2EE chat service. What I mean by that is: E2EE is a necessity, not some nice-to-have feature.

Building a chat service with server-side chat history but without E2EE is like building a car with very nice headlights that doesn't actually move.

Signal has server-side chat history, no? And the protocol is open. So that part of the argument is moot.
Signal chat history is client-side. You have to explicitly "back up" and "restore" messages to move to a new device, and if you lose your phone, your chat history is gone forever.

https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007059752-Ba...