Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ajross 1828 days ago
ALL retailers destroy unsellable inventory. Items can be defective, counterfeit, damaged, under legal injunction like a trade dispute, incorrectly licensed, or just plain unwanted. If you trade in any item anywhere eventually you're going to end up with something in stock you can't sell.

I mean, what do we want to happen? These things to sit idle forever in a warehouse taking up space?
2 comments
silicon2401 1828 days ago
Give them away for free. we should incentivize under-production, not over-production. charge more for waste disposal
link
ajross 1828 days ago
You can't give counterfeits away, you'll be sued. You can't give unlicensed or embargoed products away, you'll be fined. Give away damaged or defective goods and you'll see even worse PR than this story.

You can only give away the stuff you "could" sell but can't find a buyer for, which (1) pretty much means no one wants it and (2) will poison your relationship with the people who sell you the stuff you *can* resell!

link
romwell 1828 days ago
Yes, that's why we need to removing the externality of destroying goods (and all of us enjoying the environmental damage) by making it cost more to destroy something than to give it away (which may include refurbishment, repackaging, etc).

What, you tried selling a made-for-landfill thing that works half the time? Should've done your research. Choose your loss.

link
kleiba 1828 days ago
No producer can predict with absolute accuracy the number of items they are going to sell. If you produce too many items that you don't end up selling, you overspend on production costs. If you produce too few, you cut your revenue. Optimizing the balance between these two extremes is part of running a successful business.
link
nradov 1828 days ago
Charging more for waste disposal results in illegal dumping.
link
gruez 1828 days ago
>Give them away for free. we should incentivize under-production, not over-production

...and that's how you end up with shortages.

link
twiddling 1828 days ago
I worked in an electronics store in the '80s. Once a month we would have "TV day", where all the warehouse guys would smash old TVs and other gadgets. Great way to relieve stress...
link