[lazide]

Ah, but now you’re moving the goalposts it seems?

Since most of what we’re talking about is unnecessary complexity for no real gain, what concrete metric do you think would be useful exactly? I just pointed out that you can get the same management advantages without it (say for a dev environment or rollbacks or whatever). And you get a simpler, cleaner story without extra layers if you don’t want to use lvm (such as in production), which you can’t get from O_DIRECT.

I also have this thread from Linus calling O_DIRECT brain damaged and to never use it. [https://lkml.org/lkml/2007/1/10/233]

[josefx]

The problem is some of the alternatives seem to be suggested by way of "if we had any support for this it would be better than O_DIRECT". So don't use O_DIRECT, use the alternative which doesn't exist, is still too slow, only covers parts of what you need, etc. .

[quotemstr]

I respect Linus, but he has a problem where he never ever backtracks and admits he was wrong about something. Take C++ for example.