Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jayd16 1826 days ago
I kind of doubt drone vs drone will be all that effective. Have anti-missile systems ever been all that effective?
1 comments

Simulation of course, but I'll submit this video for your consideration:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1K8LGTwy6Zw

To sum up the conclusion of the several-hour video series: the Aegis Combat System is essentially impenetrable to all but the most overwhelming of forces.

The resurgence of battle ships? It can't counter cannons right?
Perhaps not, but missile cruisers can :) They try that in a different series, a fully armed WWII battleship group against a modern US carrier group. Guns just don't have the range compared to surface launched missiles and they can't get close enough.

I won't pretend to be some expert on military hardware, I'm a guy interested in flight sims, and that video series just happened to catch my attention. They make a compelling argument though, cruise missiles are one of the methods they try (unsure if supersonic), and they are attacking the carrier group in the absolute worst defensive position it could be in: a narrow gulf surrounded by unfriendly territory on most sides.

Still, not much gets through. If it's not the missile defense system that gets you, it's the F/A-18 patrols. If not them, it's the F-14s that can scramble in minutes. Scary stuff.

I didnt watch it, but what about a supersonic cruise missile?