Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cbsmith 1836 days ago
Keep in mind that vaccines solve a systemic problem, and a bad vaccine can exacerbate a pandemic. Yes, vaccines can be made in a day or two, but it takes a long time to know if they are effective.
2 comments

That's not addressing the parent's point about a challenge trial though. A challenge trial could greatly accelerate measuring that effectiveness.
Yes, but a challenge trial doesn't require institutional but in.
s/but in/buy in/
It actually doesn't take long to have high confidence vaccines work. Roughly 30 days. Day 1- inject vaccine. Day 15 - infect virus. Day 30 - know it works.

Human challenge studies were a ethical no brainer.

Even other studies if we gradually increased the number of people allowed to take them would mitigate almost any real risk. So you let up to 1k people take it month 1, 10k month 2, 100k month 3, and so on. Basically no meaningful extra risk but faster results.

Vaccines have a very good safety record and efficacy record, this isn't like cancer which is much more speculative.

Banning vaccines is not the answer. Most US deaths were completely preventable.

I strongly agree with reducing red tape for biomedical testing, but this is a drastic oversimplification of the current scenario, and of vaccine efficacy.
What are the odds that in hindsight, someone in your combinator would be for reducing the red tape? ;-)