Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by marsrover 1829 days ago
> The prices of these coins can and does get manipulated all the time.

This is known.

> Real people will get burned, badly.

Welcome to the game, there is a learning curve.

> You can't even depend on these exchanges to actually handle high trading volume when there are price crashes.

If they're centralized, you mean.

> It's honestly a joke that anyone trusts this system as it currently stands.

It's easy to distrust a system you don't understand.

> Anyone who seriously believes in a future of cryptocurrency should be calling this crap out

If you interacted with anyone in crypto you'd realize that they do.

> The problem: very few people actually believe in cryptocurrency, most are looking for a quick buck instead.

Why is that a problem? The ecosystem needs technologist and "market makers" (including individual traders in this) to function.

1 comments

I just want to say I like cryptocurrency, but there are some real problems with some of your points I just had to point out.

> welcome to the game.

Is this a game, or something useful, a currency system? If it's a game all your opponents are right. Truth is, some people get burned with every risk that people take, and everyone gets burned by some risk they take at some point, it is why most of us are risk averse. People get burned crossing the street.

> If they're centralized

Find me a single decentralized exchange that has the liquidity to handle high trading volume.

> It's easy to distrust a system that you don't understand

You're assuming detractors don't understand. It is self supporting fallacious logic, "if you don't agree with me that's because I know more about it than you"

As far as unaddressed points, to talk about crypto getting manipulated and pretend that heavily regulated markets like the housing market or stock market don't get manipulated is hilarious. Every market gets manipulated, but people pretend like the government solves that and cryptocurrency is the only market where this happens.

All in all I like cryptocurrency, and I don't like regulation for the most part. Before someone out there decides that this means I don't think murder should be illegal, I do, so no sense going down that line of discussion. But I don't think protecting people from predators is the same as protecting people from themselves, one is within the realm of a justice system and the other is not.

> Is this a game, or something useful, a currency system?

Do you not think the current economic system is a game? Because it is.

> single decentralized exchange...

Uniswap had no liquidity issues for blue chips with the recent crash.

Clearly there can be more liquidity in the market, but that’s not the argument.

> detractors don’t understand

Why would I think differently when they never do?

Assuming the rest of the response isn’t directed at me.