Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by marsrover 1829 days ago
Just because we do something doesn't mean we should.
1 comments

That's not an argument in either direction. We do lots of things we could instead not do, many of which we should.
If you think that's not an argument in either direction, I don't know what to tell you.
You're implying that some financial regulations are unnecessary, but without saying it or giving reasons why. Yes, I think you have no provided an argument.
Adults should be allowed to make adult decisions. Thats the argument.
That’s a poor argument. What about adults that take advantage of other adults?

Subprime? Insider trading? Organised crime?

They are all adults making decisions… why even have police? How much crime is committed by kids anyway?

You know, people talk about "there should be some protection from yourself making bad decisions" and when someone says "no there shouldn't, let people make their own mistakes" you see responses like this, "so we shouldn't ban crime?" Its absurd. It is classic straw man garbage.

Of course stealing and fraud and such should be illegal. But if I want to squander my money on bullshit, that is my right.

> What about adults that take advantage of other adults?

Well, there's a pretty big universe of meaning.

> Subprime

What is more wrong? Banks lending to people they know they can't afford it because they think the risk/reward ratio is worth it? Or governments not letting them feel the effects of the markets reaction?

> Insider trading

Honestly who gives a shit? This is the type of thing that would be quickly priced into the market.

> Organised crime

Are we talking about selling drugs? Or murder? Or sex trafficking. Because I have very different opinions between the first and the second two.

> why even have police

See above.