Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by shrimp_emoji 1835 days ago
Yes, a shitty cycle in a shitty world. If not for the threat of China, I don't think the U.S. military industrial complex would have as much merit, but, under that (growing) threat, I think anyone who values freedom, democracy, and progressive ideals should see merit in the U.S. maintaining and growing capability.

To do that, it seems like the defense industry needs "stuff to do". Like a muscle, that sector atrophies if left unused. It's counterintuitive, though -- why spend so much money on a glorified Skunk Works project like the F35? Why double down and start producing hundreds of them despite their issues? Because it generates/maintains experience and lessons and keeps the metabolic pathways that turn material into materiel active. If you skipped the extra steps and had the government just sustain the defense industry on welfare while it does nothing right up until we have a massive conflict, things are going to go much more poorly for you.

2 comments

> If not for the threat of China...

The military industrial complex will always have a bogeyman ready.

Well, some of them like Hitler and present day CCP are more wrll suited than others.
We can spend that money directly on our military.

There's no need to funnel it through Israel, which gains more of the benefit than we do.