Not "his challenger"; it was not a contest. It would be more proper to say "his reviewer, the inventor of Unix pipes, using the review column to advertise UNIX®". See a previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22406070
Incidentally, a couple of days after that thread, the current fastest submissions (which, like Knuth, all use tries) were posted at the question https://codegolf.stackexchange.com/questions/188133/bentleys... mentioned in a sibling comment. (AFAICT that comment should say "200 times faster", not "30 times faster", but anyway in light of the original context it's not meaningful to compare the two approaches either for efficiency or ease of implementation or anything else.)
Incidentally, a couple of days after that thread, the current fastest submissions (which, like Knuth, all use tries) were posted at the question https://codegolf.stackexchange.com/questions/188133/bentleys... mentioned in a sibling comment. (AFAICT that comment should say "200 times faster", not "30 times faster", but anyway in light of the original context it's not meaningful to compare the two approaches either for efficiency or ease of implementation or anything else.)