Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ThePhysicist 1839 days ago
I was curious about their claims regarding confidential computing so I checked out their Github organization (https://github.com/edge), but it seems there's very little activity there and there's not a single reference to Intel SGX (the enclave they claim to use). So I'm a bit skeptical about their claims. SGX is also not a general-purpose technology and can only run highly specialized code, to my knowledge there's currently no way to run general-purpose code that e.g. uses syscalls (there are some projects that try to fix this though).
2 comments
ignoramous 1839 days ago
> ...there's not a single reference to Intel SGX (the enclave they claim to use).

Unrelated, but amusingly, if they want to, they could use https://secret.network/ to host their workload in peer-to-peer serverless SGX enclaves, powered by the blockchain.

link
ignoramous 1839 days ago
Mea culpa: Looks like secret.network is indeed a joke website... https://scrt.network/ is what I meant to share.
link
qeternity 1839 days ago
Most blockchain projects are just an excuse to list a related crypto. It doesn’t even appear that the underlying distributed computer network has anything to do with blockchain.
link
ignoramous 1839 days ago
> It doesn’t even appear that the underlying distributed computer network has anything to do with blockchain.

I think the blockchain acts a transparency ledger among a distributed set of distrusting participants. Think: if PirateBay could pay you to seed magnet-links all the while knowing for sure you've not tampered with the the amount of bandwidth you've claimed to have lent, and the network then rewarding (paying) you the equivalent amount that you're owed for your troubles. "Blockchain" enables that.

The ICOs are akin to companies filing for IPOs. The ICOs don't strictly need speculation (because the utility of their network ideally would have an inherent, demonstrable value that dictates the price of the network's coin), but they do need the market to trade their coins, because that's how anyone participating in the network would be able to convert their rewards into fiat. (note: at this point, we're essentially reinventing Ehtereum, the super computer, as originally envisioned...)

You could aruge that many of these networks could avoid doing ICOs and simply use one of the existing cross-chain coins from Cosmos, Algorand, Polkadot (or even stable coins like USDC, Diem, Celo, BUSD, DAI etc), but it is the summer of crypto, and everyone's got to do an ICO.

link