Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ThePowerOfFuet 1836 days ago
Why cancel your old phone number in that country when you still have a bank account there?

I suggest a bank which doesn't suck, such as bunq.

4 comments

It can be costly.

I moved from Ireland to the US and kept my Irish number active - the cost was a €5 topup every 6 months.

Going in reverse is much harder - a lot of the budget phone providers in the US don't have any roaming offering. Best I can tell, you really need to have an account with a real provider, and that realistically looks like $20/mo (Google Fi), 20x more expensive than the reverse.

Then it sounds like changing bank is a better answer for many.
This oversimplifies the situation - if every US bank uses SMS and you want to retain a US bank, what do you do?
That's such a huge "if" that an alternative immediately came to mind:

TransferWise doesn't require a US phone number, but you can have a US account number with them.

Maybe they didn't know they needed a phone number to maintain access to the account?

Let's not blame the victim here.

The bank is at least equally at fault, if not more so.
I would never think my phone # was the only proof of identity.
If that's what your bank had been using during the login flow...
if you immigrate, like I did, but still have some pension funds or saving accounts in your home country. Why would I want a local phone line?
So your bank can send you the SMS you need to sign in (which in itself indicates their security is poor).
most banks don't support international numbers if that what you meant
No, that's not what I meant.
what did you mean then?
Banks which rely on SMS 2FA should not be trusted with your money.