Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Tabular-Iceberg 1835 days ago
Why isn’t it an app? What’s the criteria for something being an app?
2 comments

An app is a program that launches, does something and exits.

iCloud is an "always on" cloud storage/sync service where you choose what data you want to use it for.

How is this a meaningful distinction whatsoever? There are countless apps that allow you to sign up for an "always on" service. Should they be exempt from allowing you to delete your account as well? Or is that privilege reserved for built in bloatware?
iCloud is part of the operating system, and, most importantly, it is not downloaded through the App Store.

These rules are for apps on the App Store.

Edit to add: There may be a reasonable debate to be had over whether there should be some visible component of iCloud that has to be downloaded from the App Store before it can be used on an iDevice—or whether the App Store rules should be, by some means, applied to the entirety of what can/does run on an iDevice. But right now, neither of those are the case, and thus, though some may find the difference between "iOS" and "application running on iOS" frustratingly slim, Apple is not, in this instance, applying its rules inconsistently.

Are you being deliberately obtuse or just really not able to understand that Apple provides two things: 1) an operating system with ancillary features and 2) an App Store with applications for sale?

iCloud is not an app that you can download on the App Store. It is an ancillary service for the operating system.