Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Havoc 1842 days ago
WTF is going on with their cookie dialog? Surely that's not even remotely legal? There is just agree and a second dialog with guidance on how to clear cookies per browser (???) and a second agree button.

That's not even an attempt at a dark pattern nudging you towards one option...it's just do you agree or do you agree.

Hard to trust companies that think that's how consent works...

https://imgur.com/a/Ya1XBvG

4 comments

Facebook's own dialogue is relatively similar – you do get one option for Facebook's own advertising tracking and another for every third-party function mushed together (no differentiation between functional, analytical, advertising, etc.), but in the end no matter what you choose there's still only one 'Accept cookies' button.
I mean, it needs at least a session cookie to keep track of your login, right?
"Essential Cookies" in EU don't need a prompt.

How Github got rid of the cookie banner: https://github.blog/2020-12-17-no-cookie-for-you/

I can’t see how that is acceptable in EU. For example Max Schrems has this to say about these dark pattens: https://noyb.eu/en/noyb-aims-end-cookie-banner-terror-and-is...
He's doing great work for sure!
This comment is a huge distraction from the actual substance in the link.
>actual substance in the link.

And I'd be discussing said substance...if I could get to it without a gun-to-your-head consent

Is 'you can either consent or leave' GDPR-compliant?