Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eloff 1843 days ago
No, salted meat wouldn't make a list of the top ten causes of mortality back then. I doubt even the top 100, but I can't say for certain without doing more work than a comment is worth.

Apparently lots of people disagree with something that seems obvious? Source?

1 comments

Do you honestly think that "salted meat" would be listed on a death certificate?

Here's a source for you: https://www.nature.com/articles/jhh2008144

> Do you honestly think that "salted meat" would be listed on a death certificate?

Strawman argument.

So stomach cancer is currently 10% of cancer deaths, and cancer is currently the second leading cause of death at all ages. One can't extrapolate that back historically safely because cancer primarily affects the old and people didn't live long enough back then. But even if we just single out stomach cancer and assume incorrectly that 100% is attributed to salt, when frankly that would be a minority of stomach cancers, then it still wouldn't even make the top ten causes of mortality today. Never mind historically when people commonly died from lots of things we no longer worry about, like simple bacterial infections, childbirth, or poor dental hygiene.

The OPs argument is ridiculous and I'm surprised how many people can't see that.