Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by city17 1849 days ago
The designs are really nice, but I feel they should be more differentiated. Otherwise you can't recognize a particular person by their avatar and you might as well use identical ones for all of them.
1 comments

People are good at remembering faces, but this is for people who don’t want to use their face. I don’t think the goal is to be memorable, just an easy way to be mostly unique.
I think the problem is that if you compare one to another (check out the sunset examples) ... they don't look unique.
IMO, when used is real life scenarios actual users would start to find the unique patterns and visuals in each one. It is hard to evaluate this as a passive viewer with no vested interest in any of the names/avatars as they are presented.

Personally, I saw enough general distinctive qualities among them that I felt like if I interacted with a handful of these avatars frequently that I would notice the minor differences easily.

I'd say unique enough to differentiate people within a conversation, which is good enough for a lot of use-cases