Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by feu 1846 days ago
Closing an issue shouldn't prevent anyone from finding it though. At least on GitHub closed issues are still visible in the issue tracker.
2 comments

I think closed issues shouldn't be a problem on the current release. So why search through them?
Because - per the pattern of behavior we're discussing in this thread - some developers close old issues, whether they were actually resolved or not, and it's becoming a common practice, particularly with the appearance of bots performing this function automatically.

Also, not everyone is using the most recent release.

Some issues are not actually bugs but user errors (e.g. because they haven't read the manual). Personally I'm not sure if it's better to close such issues or keep them open with a special label.
Who search for closed issues when searching if other have the same bug?
I do, because I realized people close stale issues just because (and then there are bots that do it now too). I'm happy I can still do it, and I worry that one day someone will have a bright idea to "archive" closed issues to where they cannot be easily found.
I do. Because perhaps it's fixed in a newer version or ...