Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by adolph 1857 days ago
As long time Mac and relatively recent cross platform user, native window snapping is a joke in macOS made tolerable by Magnet. Option just changes the green button mode from new workspace (or whatever its called) to whole screen. In most Windows OSes the eponymous key plus an arrow will cycle the UI window through helpful positions of whole, half, quarter.

The sibling comment challenges the parent regarding the importance of window snapping. I used to think it wasn't a big deal. I was accustomed to mousing windows here and there and seeing bits of other things behind. After using iOS I have a new appreciation for focus, simplicity and reduced non-functional effort.

A significant amount of user-time in a standard desktop GUI is spent changing application and window contexts. Why wouldn't it be as much a first class concern as brushed metal and lickability?

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/magnet/id441258766?mt=12

2 comments

> Option just changes the green button mode from new workspace (or whatever its called) to whole screen.

Hover for a second, a tooltip will pop-up for left-snap and right-snap. If you don’t hold Option it does the workspace version like iPad where it splits into a new workspace.

I have honestly never felt the need for snapping for almost a decade. Just use multiple monitors if you really need that screen estate
Poor window management isn't a great argument for more monitors. That's just using your neck to make up for a deficient UI.
I use multiple monitors and that simply means I have to do more work to snap windows. The windows sometimes migrate from desktop to desktop upon startup and wake, and there are more of them to deal with when I want to rearrange things.