Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dashezup 1863 days ago
You would notice that the main difference between lossy and lossless formats is that lossless format keeps all of the stuff while lossy formats partially or wholly drop 20kHz+ if you compare with the spectrogram of them.

And there are good reasons to listen to lossy ones instead of lossless ones, you probably can't hear 20kHz+ sound but it will reduce your headroom if it's there, this especially matters when you play it in high volume because the vibration of the 20kHz+ sound cause could cause audio distortion. MQA is the proprietary audio encoding which deals with such problem, although it seems to be a bit debatable.

Lossless formats are especially important for music storage/archive/remixing. But I really can't hear the difference between opus-128k (vbr), mp3-320k (vbr/cbr) and lossless ones.

I just encode lossless music to opus 128k to listen to when it's possible. opus is a very decent audio format, it's wildly used for VoIP. I wouldn't go any higher than 128k for opus because it's recommended in Opus wiki[1], and I've compared the spectrogram between opus 128k (VBR) and mp3 320k (CBR) and there are only very a few of differences.

[1] https://wiki.xiph.org/Opus_Recommended_Settings

1 comments

It's more like 17k, and the energy above 20k is almost so low it probably isn't adding much headroom. Not that you need it anyway.