Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by polishdude20 1860 days ago
Yeah, the more news like this that comes out, the more I realize it's not much more than a popularity contest.
1 comments

You could easily say this about the stock market. Imagine if Buffett came out and said in advance he was going to sell all his Coke stock.
I actually agree with this analogy. However, Bitcoin is not stock - unless now, after first calling a currency, then a store of value, we magically transition to calling Bitcoin a stock-like asset.
Except that he wouldn't because he knows that would manipulate the market and he's more responsible than that.
Its not just that he's more responsible, its illegal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_manipulation
But people would continue to buy Coke. And Coke would continue to make a profit and Buffet would look stupid when the company did well, even if he was able to cause a 10% dip in the stock. It is unlikely that the world would stop drinking code because Buffet said he didn't like the stock.

Bitcoin on the other hand, has no profits and only can be successful by having everyone agree it is better to own than gold. So if Musk's opinion is followed by many other people it will bring bitcoin down for a long time.