Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by swiley 1869 days ago
Maybe I want to use vim as an interactive WYSIWYG modeling program but that doesn't mean it's in the scope of the project.

LFS belongs in your build scripts, the model the git extension use doesn't even match the git VCS model.
1 comments
IshKebab 1869 days ago
Version control of large files is clearly a reasonable thing for a version control system to do.

I think if you introspect you'll see you are defending a flaw in something you like with spurious technical objections because you don't want to admit it isn't perfect. That's understandable. Happens a lot.

link
swiley 1869 days ago
I didn't say versioning large files isn't a reasonable thing to do, I said it doesn't make sense in git.

How is it supposed to work? The LFS way where you're storing a pointer to an external http resource? Just put a script in your repo to fetch that then.

Or maybe stick the data in git's merkle tree and have a really slow repo? Why bother with LFS then?

link
IshKebab 1868 days ago
> How is it supposed to work?

One obvious improvement would be for Git to use the hash of the object rather than the pointer file when calculating tree hashes. That makes the storage method for the actual files independent of the commit hashes.

People have mentioned several other VCSs in this thread that do it already.

link