Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by whimsicalism 1871 days ago
> After all this whole concept of spending a career at someone else's company only started in the late 20th C when the industrial rev created the modern corporation.

Psh, what preceded that was far worse and also involved a lifetime of laboring for someone else's benefit.

2 comments

So? The fact that slavery- and slavery-adjacent relationships were common through a lot of human history doesn't make them acceptable now.

My take on this is that there's some part of our minds that knows we don't have to be servants to our companies. And knowing that, yet subjugating ourselves anyway creates an itch. That itch grows a little every day we wake up to an alarm and haul ourselves into the office for useless meetings. We know deep down this isn't an acceptable road for our lives. But we're here anyway, with a story that somehow justifies closing jira tickets - day in, day out.

Coincidentally, depression is an evolved mechanism for stopping you from doing something that you know deep down is unhealthy for your soul but habitual. It works by every day making it harder to do the thing you know you shouldn't do. The longer you resist it, the deeper depression burrows, until you finally can't bring yourself to make pleasantries with your spouse - or, in this case, haul yourself into the office.

For my money, burnout is a depression symptom which grows out of a long term, habitual suppression of your will. "I want X, but I can't have it because of <habitual rationalisation>". After growing up being told we can do anything, we aren't adapted for existence as a few pixels in a giant org chart. Burnout is a healthy backstop to force you to pursue the life you need, even if each day you can convince yourself you don't want it.

> So? The fact that slavery- and slavery-adjacent relationships were common through a lot of human history doesn't make them acceptable now.

I was only responding to the implicit claim of the grand parent.

FWIW, I think "that's how it always has been" has no impact on the morality of something, so I am inclined to agree with you.

But we don't need to paint a rosy picture of a lost past to critique the status quo.

Your take on depression is extremely interesting and makes a lot of sense to me due to my own experiences which I will not elaborate on. What research are you basing this on?
In some colonies. Oppression and servitude was not a universal constant.
Not merely in colonies. Feudalism was the law of the land for essentially most of the world

The yeoman artisan period has always been more myth than reality.

By the looks of it, we are going back to feudalism soon.