Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by abc11283 1878 days ago
Disclaimer: I know the foundation of Rome was largely written by Sebastian. This question still applies to Rome though, but more so to “open source companies” in general.

https://rome.tools/credits/

How many of these people are going to receive an employment opportunity from this company? How many will receive equity?

I suppose the same questions can be asked if any big project, like React, though that had FB’s backing from the get-go.

I understand that OSS needs funding from somewhere, and I am incredibly optimistic about Rome, but I’d think it a bit disheartening to be surprised by this announcement as a contributor.

2 comments

I've been keeping the core contributor team updated on the funding process since December. We've also been publicly speaking about it in the Rome Discord server too. I posted about securing funding in early April in #general.

Emanuele and Yasser both approached us during this period to offer their interest in joining and have stayed actively involved in development.

It's a good question around how to compensate the shoulders of the giants you're standing on, and I don't think anyone has a good answer for that. I think it's important to note that the credits page is meant to be as exhaustive as possible. I am not aware of many other projects that have something similar, and theirs are likely to be even longer.

In the end the community is getting value because we'll now be able to do more to improve the project than we otherwise would have. Babel most notably has struggled for funding and is even currently undergoing a serious funding shortage. It has been used as one of the poster children for the JS community and it's clear that donation-based funding isn't effective, at least on the order of magnitude required to support a team.

I appreciate the thoughtful reply. I should’ve added that I’ve seen your commitment to transparency through the whole process, so the info about Discord doesn’t really come as a surprise. Thanks and good luck!
thats not how OSS contributions work. you contribute of your own free will, they don't owe you any equity or employment. of course you'd have a leg up on hiring but they don't owe you a thing.
I know how OSS works. I just think the transition from being a community-oriented project, to one that will create a lot of value for a small group of people, will be interesting to watch.

They certainly deserve any and all success, I just wonder how those decisions will be made.