Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Aeolun 1878 days ago
> Separating the password from the email field with an extra mouse click

I think they mostly do this so SSO customers do not accidentally enter their company password on the site every time.

2 comments

Right, often those sites have customers with different SSO systems. I type my company mail address and am redirected to company SSO.

I like this more than other sites where I have to find the right button between different login options (sign in with google, sign in with facebook, sign in with sso, ...) and then have to type the company name ... whatever might be the choice the admins did there that time ...

I also think that approach was initially created by Yahoo! So they could shown the user's avatar on the password page to prove authority. Not sure whether that still is a thing somewhere, considering that a recent trend is not to verify whether an account exists ...

This is always still annoying since you type in your email, then get sent off to your SSO page - and they can never be bothered to post your email over, so now you have to enter it again.
I don't know if all of the SSO login sites do this, but Office 365 authentication makes it a huge pain in the ass to get back to the page that you tried to login from; usually you get dumped back to the home page, and have to try to navigate back to where ever it was you were.

Azure Active Directory does not make it easy to do this, with the way you have to explicitly whitelist post-back URLs, or else you get the dreaded login.microsoft.com 401 page of death, where you have to parse out information buried in the query-string to determine why you didn't get redirected properly (usually it is a trailing slash on the URL... %2F)

Agreed. It always seemed to me as analogous to the situation whereby one enters some identifying information in a phone prompt, only to have to spell it out again for a CSR. Both are just plain bad design.
I kind of agree, but that seems more of a problem with the target system.

Anyway my name is remembered on my company SSO form, and I never sign in as someone else.