Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ed25519FUUU 1870 days ago
The built-in UPS feature is very cool.
1 comments

It's very cool, until something goes wrong with it. IMHO you are better off getting an external UPS and putting some other stuff on it.
It seems much more efficient with a small, DC, li-ion UPS than an external UPS which will use an AC inverter (and now you gotta decide, spring more for pure sine wave?) and heavy lead-acid batteries.
It seems like a gimmick to me. It depends on the use case, I guess. So you have your NAS on a built-in UPS. Now what about the rest of your network? Switch? Router? Modem? You still need an external UPS.
It's mostly a gimmick, but for home/small business users I think it is actually pretty useful.

A mobile power bank-sized battery like this can probably power a NAS like this for at least 10-15 minutes (personal experience messing around with USB-C).

Most home/small business NAS usage is SMB file sharing, and SMB writes are async. Just a minute to sync writes and close the file system safely is huge for most users.

As someone who has supported a small business, just being able to handle the 5 minutes between someone running the coffee maker at the same time as the fridge and then resetting the breaker is huge.