Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by prepend 1883 days ago
Where is this money going? How are these prices set? I looked up a four letter .com I have and it’s $2400. Why?

Other domains aren’t available yet.

NFTs for names is a really good idea but it seems like the novelty is in getting acceptance and trust. Not sure why a random org should get really substantial fees for names. For ICANN we’re forced to. But for a good blockchain solution the prices should be equitable.

I understand that reselling goes to the owner, but this seems like a cash grab.

That and many domains like common first names aren’t available yet.

2 comments

I agree that the prices seem arbitrary and high, but since there's no central authority competition could drive the prices down. Eventually I think we'll get to a Let's Encrypt level of service and all of this will be free, as I don't see a technical reason anyone should pay more than the transaction costs.

The high cost does prevent abuse though, as squatting would be a bigger nuisance than it is with traditional DNS if registration were cheap/free.

There are only so many viable combinations of 4-letter domain names... $2400 seems pretty fair compared to what .com's of the same length are going for (50K-$1m+ for random 4 letter combinations)
Fair compared to what? Why should the price for one be greater than another? The price of generating an NFT is the same no matter how many combinations.

As a user, I would not want willingly join in a new name system that benefits an arbitrary company so much. ICANN forces use of domain registrars so I have no choice. A future system should be better, I think.